Man in jail accused of threatening to rape deputies

New charges against man arrested in standoff based on comments he made during call with his mom
By 
BILL SCHANEN IV
Ozaukee Press staff

A 38-year-old man who held officers at bay for 35 hours outside his Fredonia home in May 2025 added to the list of charges he faces when he told his mother in a conversation from jail recently that he intends to rape two female sheriff’s deputies who investigated his case and torture one of them, according to a criminal case filed last week in Ozaukee County Circuit Court.

Matthew K. Novak, who was arrested on May 10, 2025, after authorities knocked holes in his house, blasted him with a water cannon and shot him with a beanbag round, faces two new felony counts of threatening to cause bodily harm to a law enforcement officer. 

In connection with the standoff, Novak, who after his arrest told investigators he barricaded himself in a room of his house that allowed him to watch for people who he intended to kill if they entered his home, is charged with six felonies. Authorities said he was heavily armed and fired multiple shots from his house.

Novak has pleaded not guilty by reason of mental disease to the standoff charges and is being held in the Ozaukee County jail in Port Washington in lieu of $1 million bail. 

His case has made halting progress since charges were filed on May 27, 2025, with repeated pauses for psychiatric evaluations after both the court and his lawyer raised questions about his state of mind and whether he was competent to stand trial. 

The latest charges against Novak are based on a Nov. 4 conversation he had with his mother via a video call from jail.

Novak started the conversation by explaining to his mother that the night before he went to the jail law library and watched video turned over by prosecutors as part of discovery. The video apparently showed Ozaukee County Sheriff’s Detective Karsen Frame canvasing his neighborhood after the standoff looking for witnesses and victims, or as Novak referred to them, people “snitching” on him, according to the criminal complaint filed on Nov. 10.

Novak told his mother he remembered Frame from the standoff.

He said, “She was one of the negotiators who lied to me .... She said come outside we’ll just talk and she wouldn’t be upfront and honest with me,” the complaint states.

His mother offered perfunctory responses until interjecting, “You know, I don’t know, and we’re really not supposed to talk about the night in question.”

According to the complaint, Novak responded, “Oh, I’m talking. Oh, I’m talking. Hello Ozaukee County Sheriff’s Office and hello Karsen Frame, you will be brutally tortured. Brutally tortured, maimed, shattered, ankles shattered.”

His mother told him “stop it” and threatened to hang up if he didn’t, but Novak continued by saying, “Tell Karsen Frame she’s going to get brutally assaulted by me and then raped with a blowtorch,” the complaint states.

At another point in the conversation, Novak said, “Oh, who is her little friend, uh, the brunette one I’m raping if she doesn’t (expletive),” referring, according to the complaint, to Deputy Maddie Morgan, who also canvassed his neighborhood after the standoff.

Novak appeared to be aware during the conversation with his mother that what he was saying would result in additional charges against him.

“Did I just commit another (expletive) six felonies or something, Karsen? You know they watch these videos, right?” he said, adding later, “Is this illegal? Am I allowed to talk about that? Is that speech? I don’t know what this is. Is it hate speech?” the complaint states.

Shortly after the call between Novak and his mother ended, Frame received an email from the NCIC Correctional Services  inmate phone, messaging and video service that included an invitation to “start messaging from inmate Matthew Novak.”

A day after Novak’s conversation with his mother, a deputy assigned to the jail said Novak told him he was going to break Frame’s ankles with a bat. Novak also said he had downloaded child pornography on a jail law library computer and was going to use it to set Frame up for a possession of child pornography conviction so she would “have to go to federal prison with broken ankles and suffer,” according to the complaint. 

Another deputy assigned to the jail said that on Nov. 8 Novak asked him if it would be a felony if he broke the deputy’s shins and the shins of Frame, the complaint states.

The incident that put Novak in jail began to unfold at 8:36 p.m. Thursday, May 8, 2025, when a deputy responded to a report of loud music and gunfire in the area of Novak’s house at 139 Fox Glen Dr. Other deputies arrived to canvass the area, and at 10:14 p.m. one of them called Novak to ask if he was playing the music. Novak replied, “Oh yes, absolutely,” adding that he was also shooting guns and having a good time.

Novak also said, “So, I’m going to play some music, and if anyone comes around I shoot” before ending the call, the complaint states.

Officers left the area but returned after receiving a 911 call from a Fredonia resident who reported hearing a gunshot. At 10:58 p.m., deputies heard gunshots coming from the direction of Novak’s home.

Surveillance video from a neighbor’s home recorded as many as 100 gunshots coming from Novak’s house, including two bursts of 25 to 30 rounds, each in less than six seconds, according to the complaint.

A deputy launched a drone equipped with a camera and saw a man shooting a handgun and rifle from the back patio of Novak’s house.

The Ozaukee County Special Response Team arrived at around 11:30 p.m., informed Novak he was under arrest and ordered him to leave his house, which Novak refused to do.

During a phone conversation with negotiators, Novak said he was armed with a handgun and rifle, made one of several references to having automatic guns, mentioned using drugs such as LSD, cocaine and marijuana and said he was ready to shoot. During other conversations with officers, Novak said he took “lots of LSD” as well as heroin, the complaint states.

Novak threatened to kill officers, made reference to having an AK-47 assault rifle and told a negotiator he had a rifle aimed “at your head with night vision,” according the complaint. 

Early Friday morning, May 9, a Saukville police officer saw Novak wearing night vision goggles and pointing a rifle at an armored vehicle occupied by officers, the complaint states.

Ozaukee County Sheriff Christy Knowles said shortly after the standoff ended that authorities, who breached Novak’s home so they could see him holed up on the second floor, eventually used an unmanned fire hose to blast him.

Novak later told officers that he had no intention of leaving his house and was willing to die there until he got cold from being sprayed with water, the complaint states.

At 10:47 a.m. Saturday, May 10, Novak came down the stairs and stood in the front doorway. He ignored the commands of officers and instead flipped them off. He was eventually shot in the leg with a “less lethal” beanbag round and arrested.

Novak’s home was seriously damaged during the standoff and had to be shored up by contractors before it could be searched. When authorities were able to enter the house on May 14, four handguns, nine rifles, ammunition that included armor-piercing rounds, night vision goggles, thermal optics and electronic devices were found, Knowles said.

He faces felony charges of second-degree recklessly endangering safety, failure to comply with an officer who was trying to arrest him, intentionally pointing a firearm at an officer and three counts of harming or threatening to harm an officer. 

Novak appeared in court on Sept. 10 for a plea hearing but instead Ozaukee County Circuit Judge Steve Cain ordered another competency evaluation in response to concerns about Novak’s state of mind raised by his attorney, Jason Luczak. Based on that evaluation, Cain ruled on Oct. 21 that Novak was competent to stand trial.

He is now scheduled to appear in court on Dec. 23 for a plea hearing.

A plea of not guilty by reason of mental illness — a so-called insanity defense — deals with the defendant’s state of mind at the time the alleged crime was committed and contends that he lacked the capacity to appreciate the wrongness of his acts. Such a plea triggers a two-part process, the first of which is to determine whether he committed the crimes he is charged with, then whether he is legally responsible for them.

A person who is found not guilty by reason of mental disease is committed to the Wisconsin Department of Health Services for treatment either at a secure mental health institution or in the community.

The question of competency deals with a defendant’s current state of mind and whether he is able to understand the proceedings against him, communicate with counsel and assist in his defense. If a defendant is found incompetent, he can be ordered to undergo treatment until he regains competency.

Feedback:

Click Here to Send a Letter to the Editor

Ozaukee Press

Wisconsin’s largest paid circulation community weekly newspaper. Serving Port Washington, Saukville, Grafton, Fredonia, Belgium, as well as Ozaukee County government. Locally owned and printed in Port Washington, Wisconsin.

125 E. Main St.
Port Washington, WI 53074
(262) 284-3494
 

CONNECT


User login